Sections
Search

  • Politics
  • Economics & Finance
  • Business & Entrepreneurship
  • Art & Culture
  • Science & Technology
  • Environment & Climate Change
  • World
  • World Leaders
  • The Americas
  • Europe
  • Middle East & North Africa
  • Africa
  • Asia
  • United States
  • India
  • China
  • Russia
  • About
  • Authors
  • Publications
  • Events
  • Multimedia
  • Videos
  • Podcasts
  • Events
  • Russia
  • Publications
  • Authors
  • About
Fair Observer

MULTIMEDIA

Russians — The Great, the Gifted and the Terrible

Fair Observer

VIDEOS

FO° Exclusive: Pakistan’s Deadly Islamist Terror Attack, India’s New Water War

Fair Observer

PODCASTS

FO° Podcasts: Iran’s Axis of Resistance Is Now in Shambles. What Next?

PUBLICATIONS

Fair Observer

Support Fair Observer

We rely on your support for our independence, diversity and quality.

Donate Now
Fair Observer Logo
Support us
Search
  • FO° Events
  • Support FO°
Fair Observer Logo
History

A New Telling of the Old Story of America

In 1620, the Mayflower crew landed in North America and established Plymouth Colony, among the first permanent European settlements there. They saw this new country as a God-given land of opportunity — natives be damned. Their Mayflower Compact laid the groundwork for self-rule, shaping America’s identity and commitment to self-governance.
By Glenn Carle & Atul Singh
Glenn Carle Atul Singh
Glenn Carle, Atul Singh
@atulabhas
SHARE
June 28, 2024 05:00 EDT
comment badge
Check out our comment feature!
bookmark off

Saved Successfully.

This article saved into your bookmarks. Click here to view your bookmarks.

My Bookmarks external link icon white
foicon v1 print

A shared national story is crucial for societal unity. However, America’s traditional narrative, centered on the arrival of English Protestants to an uninhabited land destined for their control, is facing growing criticism. Critics point out that this story excludes the experiences of Native Americans and downplays the brutality of colonization.

In reality, the Mayflower settlers were neither saints nor demons but ordinary people. Some of them were Puritan Protestants seeking religious freedom; others were adventurers seeking their fortune in a new land.

The Puritans established a tradition of self-rule

Prior to landing at the coast of Massachusetts in 1620, the passengers of the Mayflower established a system of governance to ensure order. The resulting Mayflower Compact sought to control the more unruly elements by bringing them into a framework of orderly, yet democratic, rule. It established a foundation for creating laws and electing leaders from among the community. The compact became a cornerstone of American political thought and was a forerunner to the Declaration of Independence and the US Constitution. It sought to bring about law and order while also encapsulating a tradition of questioning authority and valuing individual rights.

Former CIA officer and frequent Fair Observer contributor Glenn Carle is a descendant of the Mayflower settlers. His ancestor, Stephen Hopkins, was one of the “adventurers” whom the Puritans viewed with suspicion. He had a history of challenging authority: After a previous voyage shipwrecked on then-uninhabited Bermuda, Hopkins attempted to foment a mutiny. (According to some theories, this incident may have influenced William Shakespeare’s play, The Tempest.) Hopkins’ presence was probably one of the main motivations behind the formation of the compact to control the settlers.

America’s violent history stretches back to the Puritans

As progressive and individualistic a document as the compact may have been at the time, however, it was still highly exclusive. It valued the essential equality of a king and a peasant, but only a white, Christian peasant. Native Americans were considered savages, beyond the pale of civilization and not members of the community that democracy was meant to embrace.

At times, the Puritans carried out wars of extermination against the Native Americans. In one example, the Puritans felt their position precarious and threatened by the neighboring Pequot tribe, so they slaughtered the Pequots nearly to a man.

This mixture of Christian idealism and egalitarianism with a capacity for racial exclusion and extreme violence would come to shape the American political way for centuries to come. Even today, Americans who trace their descent to southern and eastern Europe, Asia and Africa are inheritors of this tradition, whether or not they share the Protestant religion or count the Puritans as their ancestors.

The Puritans’ story, with its complexities and contradictions, continues to resonate in the American consciousness. It shapes the nation’s identity and values, its commitment to individual liberty and the ongoing need to confront the darker chapters of its past.

[Peter Choi edited this podcast and wrote the first draft of this piece.]

[Lee Thompson-Kolar edited this piece.]

ALSO AVAILABLE ON:
  • Spotify SPOTIFY
  • Spotify ITUNES
  • Spotify AMAZON

Comment

Login
Please login to comment
0 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Related Reading

FO° Conversations: Meet the Spy: Once Upon a Time in Boston

Fair Observer’s founder, CEO and editor-in-chief Atul Singh speaks at length with Glenn Carle, a retired CIA officer, geopolitical analyst...

by Glenn Carle & Atul Singh, December 14, 2022
Fair Observer

A Perspective on America’s Imperfect Democracy

In view of so many imperfections manifested throughout its history, America looks less like the “shining city on a hill”...

by Gary Grappo, January 11, 2021
Fair Observer

The Meaning and Taste of Thanksgiving

by Peter Isackson, November 23, 2016
Fair Observer

More Episodes

FO° Podcasts: Iran’s Axis of Resistance Is Now in Shambles. What Next?

This discussion covers the collapse of Iran’s Axis of Resistance, a network of militant proxies and allied states central to...

Khosro Isfahani & Atul Singh, May 3, 2025
Fair Observer

Shifting Geopolitical Winds Post-Election with Atul Singh

Rod Berger interviews Atul Singh, Founder and Editor-in-Chief of Fair Observer, to analyze the global reactions to a significant US...

Atul Singh & Dr. Rod Berger, February 15, 2025
Fair Observer

Donald Trump Is Back. The World Is Worried.

Donald Trump represents a return to isolationism and nativism, two long-standing tendencies in American politics. These tendencies have led to...

Atul Singh & Glenn Carle, February 9, 2025
Fair Observer

Religious Freedom Hangs in the Balance in Syria

HTS, an Islamist group with al-Qaeda roots, is now the strongest force in Syria. The fallen Assad regime, while brutal,...

Flavius Mihaies & Atul Singh, January 1, 2025
Fair Observer

Must Listen

Donald Trump Is Back. Why, and What Happens Now?

Antoine van Agtmael, a sage of our times who coined the term “emerging markets” in 1981, discusses Donald Trump’s victory,...

by Atul Singh & Antoine van Agtmael, December 17, 2024
Fair Observer

Making Sense of the New Trumponomics Starting in 2025

Trumponomics 2.0 combines deregulation, tax cuts and tariff threats to boost US manufacturing. How exactly this will be implemented remains...

by Christopher Roper Schell & Atul Singh, December 15, 2024
Fair Observer

Making Sense of South Africa's Rich History

South Africa's history is a journey from colonization and racial injustice to resistance and the overthrow of apartheid. In this...

by Atul Singh & Martin Plaut, November 8, 2024
Fair Observer

A Swiss Perspective on World Affairs Today

Switzerland plays a pivotal role in global diplomacy and trade, engaging in peace talks and economic partnerships across various regions....

by Thomas Greminger & Atul Singh, October 31, 2024
Fair Observer

Making Sense of Rising Tensions in the Horn of Africa

Tensions in the Horn of Africa are escalating, driven by disputes over Ethiopia’s Grand Renaissance Dam, which threatens Egypt's vital...

by Martin Plaut & Atul Singh, October 25, 2024
Fair Observer

The Quad’s Evolution From Providing Public Goods to Security Cooperation

Professor Haruko Satoh from the Osaka School of International Public Policy and Dr. Satu Limaye, Vice President and Research Program...

by Satu Limaye & Haruko Satoh, September 22, 2024
Fair Observer

Atul Singh: Journalism's Role in Addressing Democratic Decline and Propagating Diverse Perspectives

Rod Berger interviews renowned risk management expert Alan Waring. They discuss the multidimensional nature of risk, which goes beyond a...

by Atul Singh & Dr. Rod Berger, September 15, 2024
Fair Observer

Make Sense of Kamala Harris. With $200+ Million Now, Can She Win?

Since US President Joe Biden dropped his 2024 reelection bid, his Vice President Kamala Harris has gained strong momentum, quickly...

by Christopher Roper Schell & Atul Singh, August 10, 2024
Fair Observer

 

Fair Observer, 461 Harbor Blvd, Belmont, CA 94002, USA

Sections

  • Politics
  • Economics & Finance
  • Business & Entrepreneurship
  • Art & Culture
  • Science & Technology
  • Environment & Climate Change
  • World Leaders
  • World
  • The Americas
  • Europe
  • Middle East & North Africa
  • Africa
  • Asia
  • United States
  • India
  • China
  • Russia
  • Events
  • Publications
  • Authors
  • About
  • Publish
  • Contact
  • Login
Fair Observer

MULTIMEDIA

Russians — The Great, the Gifted and the Terrible

Fair Observer

VIDEOS

FO° Exclusive: Pakistan’s Deadly Islamist Terror Attack, India’s New Water War

Fair Observer

PODCASTS

FO° Podcasts: Iran’s Axis of Resistance Is Now in Shambles. What Next?

PUBLICATION

Fair Observer

Fair Observer Monthly: March 2025

Support Fair Observer

We rely on your support for our independence, diversity and quality.

Donate Now
© Fair Observer All rights reserved
Designed, Developed and Maintained by Netleon IT Solutions
Fair Observer Education Logo Fair Observer Leadership Academy Logo

    Fill below form to share your concern with us

    *Indicates required field

    BOOKMARK

    Want to save this post?
    Click to Login
    close icon n
    fo round logo close footer icon

    Support independent, crowdsourced nonprofit journalism.

    Fair Observer is a 501(c)(3) independent nonprofit. We are not owned by billionaires or controlled by advertisers. We publish nearly 3,000 authors from over 90 countries after fact-checking and editing each piece. We do not have a paywall and anyone can read us for free. With your vital donations, we can continue to do our work.

    Please make a recurring (or even one-time) donation today. Even $1 goes a long way because a million donors like you mean one million dollars. Thank you for keeping us independent, free and fair.

    One Time Monthly Yearly
    $11$111
    payment card
    new fairovserver logo red

    Sign into your Fair Observer Account

    • Lost your password?
    Forgot Password

    Forgot Password

    Enter your registered email address or username. You will receive a link to create a new password via email.

    • Log in

    Or
    Return to Login

    Forgot Password

    We have sent a link to your registered email address to reset your password.

    Back to Login

    Become a Member & Enjoy Exclusive Benefits!

    • Access to comments feature
    • Bookmark your favorite articles
    • Exclusive invitations to FO° Talks & FO° Live
    • Access to all of our e-publications
    Explore Membership
    Return to Login

    NEWSLETTER

    Make Sense of the World

    Unique Insights from 2,500+ Contributors in 90+ Countries

    close icon n

    NEWSLETTER

    Make Sense of the World

    Unique Insights from 2,500+ Contributors in 90+ Countries

    close icon n
    Fair observer

    Make Sense of the World

    Unique Insights from 2,500+ Contributors in 90+ Countries

    We Need Your Consent
    We use cookies to give you the best possible experience. Learn more about how we use cookies or edit your cookie preferences. Privacy Policy. My Options I Accept
    Privacy & Cookies Policy

    Edit Cookie Preferences

    The Fair Observer website uses digital cookies so it can collect statistics on how many visitors come to the site, what content is viewed and for how long, and the general location of the computer network of the visitor. These statistics are collected and processed using the Google Analytics service. Fair Observer uses these aggregate statistics from website visits to help improve the content of the website and to provide regular reports to our current and future donors and funding organizations. The type of digital cookie information collected during your visit and any derived data cannot be used or combined with other information to personally identify you. Fair Observer does not use personal data collected from its website for advertising purposes or to market to you.

    As a convenience to you, Fair Observer provides buttons that link to popular social media sites, called social sharing buttons, to help you share Fair Observer content and your comments and opinions about it on these social media sites. These social sharing buttons are provided by and are part of these social media sites. They may collect and use personal data as described in their respective policies. Fair Observer does not receive personal data from your use of these social sharing buttons. It is not necessary that you use these buttons to read Fair Observer content or to share on social media.

     
    Necessary
    Always Enabled
    These cookies essential for the website to function.
    Social Media
    These cookies are used to enable sharing or following of content that you find interesting on our website. These settings apply to third-party social networking and other websites.
    Performance & Functionality
    These cookies are used to enhance the performance and functionality of our website. They provide statistics on how our website is used and help us improve by measuring errors. Certain functionalities on our website may become unavailable without these cookies.
    Analytics
    SAVE & ACCEPT
    wpDiscuz

    Total Views: 3187